Code & Craft
Posted on
• Everything else

Ramayana : A Critical Review

Author
Ramayana : A Critical Review

Yesterday, I had the opportunity to watch a modern adaptation of the timeless epic, the Ramayana. While some elements were commendable, the execution was far from perfect.

The Positives

Ranveer Kapoor as Rama: Though not stellar, Ranveer Singh managed to portray Rama in a way that, while not exceptional, was serviceable. He didn't let the character down entirely.

Ravi Dubey as Lakshmana: This was one of the standout performances. I particularly liked his snarky replies, which reading the Ramayana seem true of his character.

Graphics and Visuals: The visual effects were quite impressive. There's nothing more that I can add here. The experience does not translate to words as effectively as I had hoped. The hype behind Jatayu's battle is completely justified.

Arun Govil, Shobhana, Kunal Kapoor, and Sheeba Chadda: These seasoned actors delivered strong performances. Dasharatha and Kaisesi (Shobhana) felt the most authentic. Kunal Kapoor WAS and WILL BE Indra going forward. Sheeba Chadda as Manthara was superbly apt for the role.

Yash as Ravana: Yash gave a great performance. He was menancing on the screen.

The negatives. The ones that let it all down.

Sai Pallavi’s Casting: This is perhaps the most significant misstep in the entire production. Sai Pallavi, who plays Sita, was completely miscast. Her acting was subpar, and she lacked the chemistry needed to make her relationship with Ranveer Singh feel genuine. When Sita ma is abducted, and Rama vows to make his own destiny, it felt empty.

Music by A.R. Rahman and Hans Zimmer: The music score was another major disappointment. Without mincing words, let me just say I think the both of them should be flogged for making such a botched work. The background score was very tepid for an epic as important as the Ramayana. I think Rahman should be banned from singing, plain and simple. No other way to say it.

Character Motivations: One of the most glaring issues was the misinterpretation of Ravana’s primary motivation. In the original Valmiki Ramayana, lust is the primary driver behind Ravana’s actions. Here, however, the focus was shifted to ego (Ahankara), which doesn’t provide enough substance or drive for his actions, particularly the abduction of Sita.

Miscasting: Beyond Sai Pallavi, nearly every actor seemed miscast. Their performances felt forced and out of place, detracting from the overall impact of the story.

Verdict : Maybe you can watch it once.